Philosophy's peer-review practices: some comparative dataA propos our recent discussion of whether philosophy journals should have and enforce clear peer-reviewing standards, I came across this 2011 paper by Carole J. Lee and Christian D. Schunn comparing philosophy's peer-review practices to psychology's (thanks to Feminist Philosophers for drawing my attention to it). The paper contains the results of: A study coding 423 reviews for 221 papers submitt
